Reference | Vaccine | Study population | Outcome | Vaccine efficacy or effectiveness % (95% CI), P valuea |
---|---|---|---|---|
Randomized controlled trials | ||||
Nunes 2021 [6] | PCV9 | HIV-uninfected children aged < 2y in South Africa | HCoV-associated pneumonia (any) | 64.0 (22.9–83.2), P = 0.006 |
HCoV-associated pneumonia (single viral infection) | 50.0 (-66.0–84.9), P = 0.25 | |||
HCoV-OC43-associated pneumonia | 90.9 (29.5–98.8), P = 0.004 | |||
HCoV-HKU1-associated pneumonia | 87.5 (0.1–98.4), P = 0.020 | |||
HCoV-NL63-associated pneumonia | -33.3 (-248.1–53.7), P = 0.59 | |||
Huijts 2018 [7] | PCV13 | Adults ≥ 65y in The Netherlands | HCoV-associated confirmed CAP | 23.6 (99.3%CI -54.3–62.2), P = 0.302 |
HCoV-associated suspected pneumonia | 30.6 (99.3%CI -14.0–57.8), P = 0.047 | |||
Observational studies | ||||
Lewnard 2022 [4] | PCV13 | Adults ≥ 18y in the US | Any virus detectedc | |
HCoV-associated LRTI or pneumoniad | 27.4 (4.5–44.7) | |||
HCoV-associated LRTI (non-pneumonia) | 51.4 (6.0–74.9) | |||
HCoV-associated pneumonia | 23.5 (-4.1–43.8) | |||
Hospitalized HCoV-associated LRTI or pneumonia | 19.9 (-13.1–43.2) | |||
Non-hospitalized HCoV-associated LRTI or pneumonia | 38.7 (2.6–61.4) | |||
Single virus detected | ||||
HCoV-associated LRTI or pneumonia | 31.5 (5.9–50.1) | |||
HCoV-associated LRTI (non-pneumonia) | 55.3 (-12.9–82.3) | |||
HCoV-associated pneumonia | 32.7 (4.8–52.5) | |||
Hospitalized HCoV-associated LRTI or pneumonia | 32.5 (-1.2–55.0) | |||
Non-hospitalized HCoV-associated LRTI or pneumonia | 40.8 (-2.7–65.9) | |||
Lewnard 2021 [8] | PCV13 | Adults ≥ 65y in the US | COVID-19 diagnosis | 35 (28–72)b |
COVID-19 hospitalization | 32 (17–43)b | |||
Fatal COVID-19 hospitalization | 32 (5–51)b |